What's the prognosis for the clubs on football's sick list?
Bizi Takip Edin Futbol ekonomisi facebookta futbol ekonomisi twitterde
x
Hata
  • JUser::_load: Unable to load user with id: 62

What's the prognosis for the clubs on football's sick list?
Matt Slater- 20 March 2012/ BBC sports news reporter  There was a single day earlier this month when two Championship clubs were banned from signing players because of financial irregularities, Port Vale confirmed they would go into administration and Portsmouth's administrator suggested the club might not get out of administration.

Oh, and then there was Rangers.

After a fortnight of headlines from Fratton Park, Ibrox, Vale Park and elsewhere, here is your cut-out-and-throw-away guide to football's current "insolvency events".

Port Vale

The Valiants took shelter from their creditors on 9 March after a month of thinking about who would pay the administrator fees.

Stoke-on-Trent City Council eventually took the hit but it was probably the right result as the council is on the hook for the biggest loss, a sum close to £1.9m. A cynic might add that liquidated football teams do not play well come election time.

PORT VALE

  • Club: Port Vale (Valiant 2001) Football Club Ltd
  • Founded: Formed in 2003 to rescue Port Vale FC, which was founded in 1876
  • Administrators: Gerald Krasner, Bob Young & Steve Currie of Begbies Traynor, experienced trio who have performed similar operations at Bournemouth, Leeds United & Port Vale, so they know the patient's history
  • Problem: HMRC winding-up petition over unpaid taxes, £3-4m of total debt, chronic disharmony in board room
  • Prognosis: No chance of promotion but patient should start to feel better soon

The council's entanglement with Port Vale goes back to 2006 when it loaned the club £2.25m at a reasonable rate over 20 years. Not an onerous burden for a well-run club, but clearly too much for Vale.

After a relatively successful 1990s, they were relegated to the third tier in 2000 but failed to rebalance the books. Administration followed two years later. What emerged was a fan-backed consortium with good intentions but too many factions and not enough money.

 

Thanks to the council and another £240,000 from famous fan Robbie Williams, the club bumped along for a few years only to get relegated again and finally collapse a week or so ago.

This brought Bob Young of Begbies Traynor  back for his second rescue act in less than a decade, only this time he brought the firm's football heavyweight, Gerald Krasner, with him.

 

Krasner is best known for his valiant (no pun intended) effort to save Leeds United from ruin. He failed but perhaps lessons have been learned. Within a few days of getting his hands on the books, Krasner announced the club had solid foundations, great supporters and plenty of suitors.

 

Things have rattled on at such a pace that he is now confident of wrapping up the bidding process this week and getting the all-important pence-in-the-pound deal with creditors signed off by April. It will be the perfect administration if true.

 

Portsmouth

Pompey know the way to Companies Court, too, this being their third helping of insolvency since 1999.

PORTSMOUTH

  • Club: Portsmouth Football Club (2010) Ltd
  • Founded: Set up in 2010 as part of operation to save club founded in 1898
  • Administrators: Trevor Birch, Ian Gould and Bryan Jackson of PKF. Birch has previously worked on Chelsea, Derby County, Everton, Leeds United and Sheffield United
  • Problem: Recurring tax pain, owner under arrest, previous owners clutching IOUs, impending relegation, crumbling infrastructure, £4-5m in total debts
  • Prognosis: Very worrying but support network is strong

I am going to take it as read that you know something of the Portsmouth story: the sugar daddy, the fantasy football team, the FA Cup, AC Milan at Fratton Park, the mother of all hangovers.

Their last administration in 2010 - the Premier League's first - was bad enough. That it should happen again so soon afterwards is either unfortunate or disgraceful, depending on your point of view.

 

The latter was certainly the opinion of HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) last month when it forced the club to seek bankruptcy protection over a new £2m tax bill and then demanded its choice of administrator.

 

After a lively court debate, HMRC got its man, Trevor Birch,  a former footballer turned financial fireman.

Unlike the calm commentary from Krasner, Birch has made no secret of his shock at just how bad the books are - a dozen players earning more than £600,000 a year and one earning three times that with more than a year to go on his contract - and has said nothing about bidders queuing around the block.

And why would they? The last owner but one is owed £17m (and he has a claim for an additional £10m on the last owner, who is fighting extradition to Lithuania for fraud), and the last owner but four gets a big chunk of the next four lots of Premier League parachute money.

 

This is Sacha Gaydamak, the son of a prominent Israeli businessman who funded the fun years but is now a party pooper with strips of "redevelopment land" around Fratton Park that keep him locked in a loveless union with his former fancy.

 

So Birch has his work cut out, particularly as the team look destined for League One.

"Why waste people's time with false statements about how great a bargain this club is?" Birch told me. "There is a fantastic club here - and it can be picked up again - but I am working every hour of the day just to get it to a position where it is worth saving."

 

Rangers

If the administrator's glass is half full at Port Vale and half empty at Pompey, it is sometimes hard to tell if the administrators even have a glass at Rangers. In fact, it is hard to tell if they are even administrators.

RANGERS

  • Patient: The Rangers Football Club PLC
  • Founded: 1872, 140 years of unbroken success
  • Administrators: Paul Clark and David Whitehouse of Duff & Phelps, new to this field but come highly recommended
  • Problem: Acute tax crisis, confused ownership issues, problems with authority, legal headaches, £40-90m of debt (further tests required)
  • Prognosis: Still too early to tell but the spirit is willing

At the time of writing, the experts from Duff and Phelps  (D&P) are heading to court to explain how they botched the process of putting the Old Firm giants into administration last month and why they should be allowed another chance to do so.

 

The mistake they made on that remarkable Valentine's Day was to forget to ask the UK's banking regulator, the Financial Services Authority (FSA), if it minded Rangers being placed in D&P's emergency care.

 

FSA approval is not a typical requirement because few football clubs ever come under the financial watchdog's auspices. But Rangers did when they toyed with the idea of issuing a credit card in 2008, an idea they dropped and then forgot about, apparently.

 

All very embarrassing, particularly in a week when the administrators had been hoping for some respite after a bruising start to their rescue mission.

 

The erstwhile joint administrators, Paul Clark and David Whitehouse, might have temporarily become interim managers as a result but their powers were basically the same, as were their responsibilities.

While the FSA snafu was a storm in a teacup, it did reveal two problems facing Clark and Whitehouse as they try to save a British cultural institution and global sports brand: one, they have no football experience; and two, they work for an American-owned firm based in England.

 

Taking that second point first, a clerical error like failing to check whether a company is FSA-registered can often be dealt with quickly and quietly by English judges. That is not the case north of the border.

The interim managers have also experienced some hairy moments with Scottish contempt of court laws, which are slightly different to the English ones. No harm has been done but you wonder whether they should be learning this stuff on such a high-profile job.

 

Not knowing the Scottish scene as instinctively as a local firm has had another effect that has been compounded by this being D&P's first football administration: the intense interest in their every move has, at times, mangled the message.

 

Knowing that they were perceived to be in the pocket of the club's controversial owner Craig Whyte, Clark and Whitehouse have gone to great lengths to prove their independence.

There is one other point worth making about D&P's outsider status, however: no Scottish firms wanted the work because they feared for their windows.

 

And that should tell you everything you need to know about which of the current administrations in British football will be the hardest to resolve successfully.{jcomments on}

                    linkedin-logo Paylaş                        Flipboard -logo Paylaş

Bu İçerik  13115  Defa Okunmuştur
 

Degerli yazarimiz Çarşamba, 27 Kasım 2024.

YAZARIN DIGER YAZILARINI GORMEK ICIN TIKLAYIN

Neden Futbol Ekonomisi?

 

www. Futbolekonomi.com’un  vizyon ve misyonu temel olarak  Futbol Ekonomisi Stratejik Araştırma Merkezi’nin (FESAM) vizyon ve misyonuna paralel ve aynı düzlemdedir.

 

Bu bağlamda temel misyonumuz: Futbolun yerel ve küresel makro özelliklerini incelemek ve yeni yapısal modeller önermek; bu kapsamda entelektüel gelişimi hızlandırmak ve buna ilişkin referans olabilecek bir database oluşturmak ve bunu tüm futbol araştırmacılarının emrine sunmak... Bu amaçla yapılan çalışmaları yayımlamak; gerekli her türlü bilimsel futbol araştırma ve geliştirme projelerine entelektüel anlamda destek vermek.

 

Temel Vizyonumuz: Önerilen yeni modellerin gerçekleştiğini görmektir.

 devamı >>>

finansal-futbol-anim-1

tugrulaksar_ge_roportaj

Tuğrul Akşar Güngör Urasın sorularını yanıtlıyor

  Yazar Tuğrul Akşar,
Milliyet Gazetesi Yazarı Güngör Uras'ın
sorularını yanıtlıyor.
detay için tıklayınız..

 

Spor Endexi

 

05/11/2024

Kapanış Günlük
Değişim %
  BİST 100

8.698,48

-0,17

 bjk BJKAS

4,48

-2,18

 fb FENER

100,30

0.00

 gs GSRAY

6,83

+0,15

 trabzon TSPOR

0,93

0,00

   SPOR ENDEKSİ

3.075,321

-0,41

Videolar

Tuğrul, Tuğrul Akşar, Pusula, Ekonomi, Futbol, Futbol Ekonomi, Mali,VİDEONUN DEVAMI VE DİĞER VİDEOLAR İÇİN TIKLAYIN.

İstatistikler

İçerik Tıklama Görünümü : 43573868

TRENDYOL SÜPER LİG 2024-2025 SEZONU

  

 

 Sıra TAKIMLAR 0 G B M A Y AV

1

Galatasaray 11 10  0 32 11 21 31
2 Fenerbahçe 11  8   2 1 27  9   18

26

3 Samsunspor 12 8 1  3

24

13 9

25

4 Eyüpspor 12  6   4  2 18  11 7 22
5 Beşiktaş 11 6 3  2  19  10 9 21
6 Göztepe 11 5 3 3 19  13 

  6

 18 
7

Sivasspor

12 5  2  5   17 20 -3 17
8 Başakşehir 11 4 4

17  14 3 16
9 Kasımpaşa 12 3 5 4 16    19  -3 14
10 Konyaspor 12 4 2 6 14  20 -4 14
11 Antalyaspor 12 4 2 6

15

24   -9 14
12 Rizespor 11 4 1 6 10  19 -9 13
13 Trabzonspor 11 2 6

3

12  14  -2  12
14 G.Antep FK 11 3 3 5 15 18 -3 12
15 Kayserispor 11 2 6 3 11 16 -5 12
16

Bodrumspor

12

3

2 7 10 16 -6 11
17 Alanyaspor 11 2 4 5 9 14  -5 10
18 Hatayspor 11 3 7 10 18  -8 6

19

A.Demirspor 11 0 2 9 9 25 -16

 

                 

Okur Yazar


Futbolun ekonomisi, mali, hukuksal ve yönetsel kısmına ilişkin varsa makalelerinizi bize gönderin, sizin imzanızla yayınlayalım.

Yazılarınızı  info@futbolekonomi.com adresine gönderebilirsiniz. 

 

 

Annual Review of Football Finance 2023

Annual Review of Football Finance 2023

Deloitte Sports Grup'un Avrupa Futbol Finansmanına ilişkin 32. kez düzenlediği yıllık futbol finans raporuna göre, Avrupa futbol pazarı 2021 - 22 sezonunda bir önceki yıla göre %7 büyüyerek 29.5 Milyar Euro büyüklüğüne ulaştı. Rapora ulaşmak için tıklayınız

Deloitte Money League - 2024

Deloitte Money league 2024

Deloitte Money League Raporunu 27. kez yayınladı. Rapora göre Avrupa'nın en zengin 20 kulübünün 2022-23 sezonunda gelirleri toplam 10.5 Milyar Euro'ya ulaştı. Raporu okumak için tıklayınız.

UEFA Kulüp Finans&Yatırım Raporu 2024

 

UEFA Raporu-2023

UEFA Kulüp futbolunun finansal durumları ve yatırımlarına ilişkin yıllık görünüm ve benchmark raporunu yayınladı. Okumak için tıklayınız

 


 

2021-Money-league-Raporu

 

Yirmidördüncü Deloitte Money League raporuna göre Barcelona'nın 715.1 Milyon Euro'luk geliriyle ilk sırada yer aldığı, tamamı merkez lig kulüplerinden oluşan ve bir önceki yıla göre gelirleri %12 azalan Para Ligi raporunu okumak için tıklayınız

 


 

 

annual report 202021 photo

 

Avrupa Futbolunun patronu UEFA’nın gelirleri 5.7 Milyar Euro’ya Ulaştı. Raporu okumak için tıklayınız.

 


 

 UEFA-Kulup-Futbolu-Lisanslama-2023


UEFA’nın 2023’te yayınladığı en son  Kulüp Lisanslamaya İlişkin Karşılaştırma raporuna göre kulüpler Pandemi döneminde 7.3 Milyar Euro zarar ettiler. UEFA raporu, Avrupa kulüp futbolunun endişe verici bir resmini çiziyor. Raporu okumak için tıklayınız.

 


    

191112 Aktifbank Ekolig

 

Türk futbolunun gelirlerinin ve ekonomik görünümünün mercek altına alındığı Futbol Ekonomi Raporu – EkoLig'in dördüncü sayısı yayınlandı. Süper Lig’in 2017-2018 sezonu sonunda 3,2 milyar TL olan geliri, 2018-19 sezonunda 4,2 milyar TL’na ulaştı. Bkz.

 

 

master bm report lowres

 

The European Club Footballing Landscape 2022


UEFA'nın Avrupa Lulüp futboluna ilişkin 13, kez yayınladığı, Covid-19'un etkilerinin de analiz edildiği raporu okumak için Bkz.


 

 EkoSpor-y

“Ekospor’un aylık bültenlerinden haberdar olmak için tıklayınız”

 

Süper lig Marka değeri araştırma

''Taraftar Algısına Göre Türkiye Süper Ligi Marka Değerini Etkileyen Faktörlerin ve Marka Değeri Boyutlarının Değerlendirilmesi'' Prof. Dr. Musa PINAR öncülüğünde yapılan bu araştırmayı okumak için tıklayınız.

 

 

the-european-elite-2019

KPMG Avrupa’nın 32 Elit Kulübünün değerlemesini yaptı. Süper Lig’den Galatasaray ve Beşiktaş’ın da bulunduğu bu raporda en değerli kulüp 3.2 Milyar Euroluk değeriyle Real Madrid oldu. Raporu okumak için tıklayınız.
 

Endustriyel_futbol

 

Futbolda Endüstriyel Denge ve Başarı Üzerine

Futbolun Endüstriyel gelişimi, kulüplerin sportif ve iktisadi/mali yapılanışını derinden etkiliyor. Dorukhan Acar’ın Kurumsal Yönetim temelli yaklaşımı ile "Futbolda Endüstriyel Denge ve Başarı"yı okumak için tıklayınız

 

 

Türkiye'de Kadın Futbolunun Gelişimi ve Günümüzdeki Durumu

 

imagesCAVM4O4L

 

Dr. Lale ORTA’nın Kadın Futboluna Entelektüel Bir Yaklaşım Sergilediği makalesi için tıklayınız.” 

 

 

İngiliz Futbolunda Kurumsal Yönetişim Üzerine

 

governance_in_football

 

Tüm kulüplerimize ve Türk Futbol yapılanmasına farklı bir bakış açısı kazandırabileceğini düşündüğümüz, İngiliz Parlementosu’nun Kültür, medya ve spor Komitesi’nin hazırladığı raporu okumak için tıklayınız. 

 

money-and-soccer

“Money scorring goals”, Gerçekten de “Para Gol Kaydedebiliyor mu? “

Euro 2012’nin olası ekonomik etkilerini
okumak için tıklayınız. 



FFP

Futbolda Finansal Sürdürülebilirlik Kapsamında ''Finansal Fair Play Başa Baş Kuralı ve Beşiktaş Futbol Kulübü Üzerinde Bir Uygulama 
Hüseyin AKTAŞ/Salih MUTLU,

okumak için tıklayınız.